The Hidden Downsides of Meditation: A Guide for Physicians

As a physician coach and certified mindfulness meditation teacher, I find meditation to be a powerful and sustaining practice.

Meditation, especially a mindfulness practice, has been shown to improve focus and to mitigate stress and burnout. It can even improve sleep quality.

But while meditation has numerous benefits, there are also a few drawbacks that are not often discussed. With widespread recommendations for meditation and meditation apps, it’s important to keep in mind that meditation is not for everyone.

For some people, meditation may have unintended, and unexpected consequences. In some cases, simply changing the time of day or duration of practice can make all the difference. In this article, we’ll explore the potential downsides, along strategies for getting the most benefit from meditation and mindfulness practices.

Mental Health Impact

Because of its inward focus, meditation can sometimes bring up uncomfortable emotions or past traumas. People with diagnosed anxiety often benefit from meditation, but they may be especially vulnerable to this negative effect.

Of course, it’s normal to feel a little anxious when you are not accustomed to sitting quietly. Cultivating stillness can take time. But if the anxiety does not lessen, or if you are not able to let go of uncomfortably intrusive thoughts, then meditation may not be right for you.

And while detachment is often a goal of mindfulness meditation, some people may develop a distressing sense of detachment from reality.

Longer meditation sessions, including meditation retreats, are more likely to cause this type of trouble. If you are prone to anxiety or depression, it makes sense to keep your sessions to 20 minutes or less and to approach meditation gently.

Seek professional guidance if intense emotions or memories arise that are difficult to manage on your own.

Insomnia

Mindfulness meditation can improve your sleep quality. But a focused meditation at bedtime might actually cause the mind to become more alert, making it harder to fall asleep.

Consider meditating in the morning, mid-day, or before you head home from work. That way you’ll refresh your mind and gently reset your focus for the rest of the day ahead.

Decision Making

For many people, mindfulness meditation can improve decision-making speed and help with goal setting for positive outcomes.

But if you are someone who consistently tries to find the “best” possible choice when making decisions, you may find that mindfulness practices actually make it harder for you to make decisions. Instead of taking action, you might find yourself ruminating on all the possible outcomes.

Physical Discomfort

Sitting for extended periods, especially without proper support or in an uncomfortable posture, can lead to physical discomfort, including back pain, stiffness, or joint pain.

When meditating, ensure you are sitting in a comfortable position, perhaps using cushions or a chair for support. You might even find it more comfortable to meditate lying down.

Another option to consider is walking meditation. You can find these types of meditations on most meditation apps.

Many people are not aware that the physical practice of yoga developed as a way to prepare the mind and body for meditation. Yoga works by releasing stress and strain in the muscles and guiding you to consciously slow down your breathing pattern.  When time permits, consider incorporating gentle stretching or yoga before meditation.

Conclusion

While meditation can be a powerful tool for improving focus, reducing stress, and enhancing sleep, it’s important to be aware of its potential downsides.

By starting with shorter sessions, being mindful of any arising emotions or negative feelings, and ensuring a comfortable posture, you can minimize risks.

Reach out to your mental health professional if you feel that meditation has aggravated or brought on uncomfortable feelings or persistent symptoms.

For many people, setting the stage for meditation with gentle stretching or yoga may offer a more sustainable and beneficial experience.  

If meditation isn’t for you, don’t force it. Instead, you can find a similar mental reset by simply taking a brief walk or finding a minute between patients to take a few slow, deep, purposeful breaths.

---

If you’ve enjoyed this article and would like to stay in the loop for more insights on creating a sustainable, fulfilling, and happy life as a physician, sign up for my newsletter or reach out on my website. I’d love to hear from you.

If you’d like to learn more about my coaching practice, you can schedule a complimentary introductory meeting by clicking the link below.